| Ideal Level of Achievement | Standard Level of Achievement | Unacceptable Level of Achievement) |
1: Crystal structure | It is possible to explain the definition of the crystal and explain the brave lattice using formulas and diagrams | It is possible to show the brave lattice as a figure or express a conditional expression | It is impossible to show the brave lattice as a figure or express a conditional expression |
2: Reciprocal space | Understand the dimensions of real space and wavenumber space and explain it by combining with diffraction phenomena | Understand the difference between real space and wavenumber space and calculate the diffraction condition. | Misunderstand the difference between real space and wavenumber space and calculate the diffraction condition. |
3: Thermal equilibrium and entropy I | Understand the difference between closed and open systems and it is possible to explain equilibrium condition. | UUnderstand the difference between a closed system and an open system and describe equations of the equilibrium condition. | It is impossible to describe the equations of equilibrium condition. |
4: Thermal equilibrium and entropy II | It is possible to explain about Boltzmann statistics and Gibbs free energy in conjunction with the constraints of the assumed system. | Describe the formulas of Boltzmann statistics and Gibbs free energy. | It is impossible to describe the formulas of Boltzmann statistics and Gibbs free energy. |
5: Lattice vibration (Phonon) | It is possible to show the wave equation of the wave propagating in the crystal and derive the propagation velocity in conjunction with the crystal orientation. | Show the wave equation of the wave propagating in the crystal and explain that the propagation speed varies depending on the
crystal orientation. | It is impossible to show the wave equation of the wave propagating in the crystal and explain that the propagation speed varies depending on the crystal orientation |
6: Fermi particle and Bose particle | It is possible to explain the features of Fermi particle and Bose particle and describe each distribution function. | Explain the features of the Fermi particle and Bose particle. | It is impossible to explain the features of Fermi particle and Bose particle. |
7: Energy band | It is possible to explain the difference between conductors, semiconductors, and insulators using a band structure. | Explain the band structure and differences between conductors and
insulators. | It is impossible to explain the band structure and difference between conductors and insulators. |
8: Dielectric materials | It is possible to explain the electrical properties of insulators and the polarization of the dielectric fenomena. | Explain the electrical properties of insulators. | It is impossible to explain the electrical properties of insulators. |
9: Magnetic materials | It is possible to explain the difference between magnetization and magnetic susceptibility, diamagnetism and paramagnetism and evaluate magnetic material from hysteresis loop. | Explain the differences between magnetization and magnetic susceptibility, and diamagnetism and paramagnetism. | It is impossible to explain the difference between magnetization and magnetic susceptibility, diamagnetism and paramagnetism. |
10: Superconduction | It is possible to explain the features of superconductor from the expression mechanism and to
describe the properties of superconductivity required for industrial applications. | Enumerate features of a superconductor and show the properties of superconductivity used in industrial applications. | It is impossible to explain the superconductivity. |